Secretary of State records show existence and good standing for corporate and other registered entities. Organizational documents show the entity’s governance structure. However, a certificate of incumbency and authority (COI) goes further and confirms who can actually sign for and bind an entity to a lease. COIs are therefore hugely important in the leasing world but are often underappreciated. This article will outline why COIs are so important and some practical options and considerations for lessors.
In order for a corporate or other registered entity to enter into a legally binding lease, the signer must be authorized to do so. This is typically done via a resolution or consent in lieu of a board meeting. A COI provided by a secretary or assistant secretary of a corporate or other registered entity 1) confirms that a resolution has been passed authorizing the lease, 2) confirms the official capacity of the signer, 3) confirms the sample signature of the signer, and 4) confirms the authority of the signer to bind the entity to the lease.
It is possible for an entity to enter into a lease in the ordinary course of business without a resolution if authorized in the entity’s bylaws or under a theory of “apparent authority” (discussed below). However, without carefully examining the bylaws, or in the case of apparent authority, all of the relevant facts and circumstances, a lessor will not know what the specific signing authority is or what is in the ordinary course of business for the entity.
Apparent authority is a legal concept that permits an officer, employee, or agent of an entity to bind such entity to a contract based on the counterparty’s reasonable belief in light of the entity’s actions or manifestations that the officer, employee, or agent has the authority to act on behalf of the entity entering into the contract, even if such authority has not been expressly granted by the board of directors via a resolution or under the entity’s bylaws. This concept is very fact specific and typically involves a court examining all the applicable facts and circumstances.
Therefore, other than for relatively small business transactions in the ordinary course, it is standard practice for lessors to require a COI. COIs help greatly reduce the risk that the lessee later claims that the signer lacked authority or that the lessee failed to obtain all required internal approvals. Most lessors designate a dollar threshold for when they will require a COI. This dollar amount varies by risk appetite for lessors, but common thresholds in the industry are often between $100,000-$250,000.
On its face, the importance of COIs sounds very straightforward. Problems arise when a lessee refuses to provide a COI on the basis that the deal is “small enough” in the view of the lessee to not justify going through the “trouble” of getting a COI signed by the lessee’s secretary or assistant secretary. For instance, a major “box company” may view a $1 million forklift lease as small in the context of its own business operations. When this happens, here are some practical considerations to keep in mind:
A representation in the lease that the lease was duly authorized and executed is generally not sufficient because if the lease itself was not duly authorized and executed, such representation would similarly not be authorized.
Reliance on apparent authority is often employed by lessors when the lease at issue is below the designated threshold for requiring a COI or in those cases above such threshold where the lessee refuses to provide same. As noted above, this is a highly fact-specific analysis rather than a bright-line rule and will depend on all the facts and circumstances, including the nature and size of the transaction, whether it is consistent with the ordinary course of the lessee’s business, the type of equipment, the position or title of the signer, and the lessee’s conduct or representations. For instance, a small deal, having a very senior title (e.g., CFO or President) for standard office equipment would likely be very helpful facts when making the above analysis. This analysis becomes more complex and potentially riskier depending on the applicable facts, which underscores the need for, and the greater certainty provided by, COIs.
Programmatic support, including a loss pool or other forms of recourse or indemnification, and/or strong programmatic representations from the equipment vendor/supplier can help when properly drafted. Of course, this effectively shifts the risk to relying on the single program partner at issue rather than spreading the risk out amongst a larger pool of lessees.
The lessee making payments under the lease can help reduce the risk because as more payments are made, it will become harder for a lessee to plausibly argue that it had not authorized and/or ratified the lease by making such payments and indeed continuing to use the leased equipment. While there is no absolute magic number, it is common to view three to six payments as a relatively safe number to evidence ratification of the lease even if the lease was not specifically authorized. In essence, receipt of such payments helps to reduce this risk with enough time and payments.
It is often not necessary for a lessee to convene a special board meeting to pass a specific resolution authorizing a lease or a master lease. In many cases, entities will have already passed a general “omnibus” resolution authorizing the type of lease that a company views as being routine and/or in the ordinary course. An entity’s secretary or assistant secretary is charged with being knowledgeable with the entity’s formation and governance documents and its corporate minutes. Therefore, such secretary or assistant secretary should readily be able to certify whether the entity has authorized a lease and confirm authority of the signer to bind the entity to the lease.
For certain types of entities, it may be necessary to obtain multiple COIs. For example, where authority flows through one or more managing members, general partners, trustees or parent entities, a separate COI may be required at each level of the ownership or governance structure to establish that each person signing the lease has the requisite authority to bind the applicable entity. For such lessees, the apparent authority analysis would be more difficult to establish, and COIs may require review and customization.
As an alternative to a COI, a lessee could arrange for an external law firm to provide a legal opinion confirming due authorization and execution of the lease. However, this would be an additional expense for the lessee.
A lessee might instead offer to provide an in-house legal opinion because there would not be an out-of-pocket expense. Some lessors are reluctant to accept internal opinions generally given that in-house attorneys do not carry malpractice insurance. However, depending on the title and role of the lawyer and the dollar amount and other relevant facts, an internal legal opinion should help with the “apparent authority” analysis.
One caveat when dealing with COIs: it is virtually never appropriate for the secretary or other officer to confirm his or her own signing authority for obvious reasons.
In conclusion, COIs are important to establish that a lease has been validly authorized by an entity and that the signer is authorized to sign for and bind such entity. Given that leases involve a cash outlay by a lessor for a lessee’s acquisition of equipment, requiring a COI should not objectively be viewed as unreasonable. And indeed, in most cases it should be a very straightforward matter for a secretary or assistant secretary to provide. In the event that a lessee objects, the above considerations should provide some practical guidance to move things forward.